John A. Donaldson.

Living Document · July 2026

Movies without tension (that aren't boring)

A working list of films that never reach for your pulse — parody, comic competence and formal artifice — assembled for a teenager who bolts at the first sign of tension.

A viewing list for the kid who bails on tension

Last updated: 25 July 2026

Is your teenage son anything like mine?

He grew up on YouTube — not the original experimental YouTube, where three guys in a garage posted something odd and hoped, but the post-takeover atrocity that replaced it. He fast-forwards by reflex. He hates romance. He cannot do tension, or rather he manages it fine, provided he holds the remote and skips the middle.

Taking him to the movies costs me something. He barely survived Flow. The cute animals helped. The animation earned an A+. The global-warming-disaster-waiting-to-happen made the whole thing tough to tough out. Watching at home runs no easier, not unless you accept a boy who bolts. Every romantic kiss sends him out of the room — which killed the I-forgot-how-much-girlfriend-plot-this-had Karate Kid. Any cynicism sends him out — which killed the was-the-opening-always-this-bleak Galaxy Quest. Tension of any kind sends him out — which killed The Last Starfighter, for goodness sake.

So he watches films alongside other people, in a theatre or on the couch, only on terms. Those terms turned out tougher than I expected, and considerably more interesting.

The terms

  1. The film must never try to raise your pulse. How it ends tells you nothing. Ask instead whether the direction wants you tense — Mission: Impossible wants it badly, Airplane! never asks.
  2. Romance may appear. Romance may not drive. Settled fact passes. Punchline passes. Engine fails.
  3. The plot must carry itself. Nothing that collapses without prior investment in music or sport.
  4. No bullying as structure. Incidental mockery survives. Biff Tannen does not.
  5. No cynicism, above all in the opening. The first ten minutes decide whether anyone stays.
  6. Animals welcome. Dead animals are not. Also nothing cloying.
  7. Comic violence passes. Cartoon physics defuses everything.

That first term carries the rest, and it deserves an argument.

Why “nobody dies” fails as a test

Most people asked for a film without tension answer a different question. They answer with outcome. Nobody dies, the dog lives, the hero wins, so relax.

That answer fails, and it fails instructively. Everyone watching Mission: Impossible knows Ethan Hunt survives. Everyone knows it. Everyone still grips the armrest while he dangles off the Burj Khalifa, because Brad Bird engineered ninety seconds to produce exactly that grip and outcome never entered the calculation. Airplane! runs the opposite way. A plane full of passengers faces death by food poisoning and nobody in the audience tightens a muscle, because Zucker and Abrahams never once ask for it.

Direction governs the response, not plot. Which reframes the search entirely: stop asking how a film ends and start asking whether it wants your pulse at all.

Three mechanisms disable the wanting.

Parody converts jeopardy into citation. Danger arrives in quotation marks and quotation marks cannot frighten anyone. Airplane II stages its climax on a Star Trek bridge where crewmen vocalize the door sounds with their own mouths — swish, swish — and any threat the scene might have carried dissolves into that one joke.

Comic competence caps the worst outcome at humiliation. Inspector Clouseau cannot suffer harm. He can only suffer embarrassment. Jack Burton spends Big Trouble in Little China convinced he stars in the film while Wang Chi does the actual saving, and Carpenter drains the menace by making his hero useless.

Formal artifice keeps you outside the frame. Stop-motion peril reads as craft. Nick Park can send a train through a bakery and you watch the plasticine.

A fourth mechanism exists — bounded stakes, where the worst outcome amounts to losing the game. Cool Runnings, Moneyball, School of Rock. In theory it satisfies every term above. In practice my son found all three boring, which taught me something the taxonomy alone would have missed: removing tension removes a load-bearing wall, and a film has to build something else in its place.

Try these

Parody, the safest ground

Airplane! — the tension runs so tongue-in-cheek as to preclude bolting-behavior. Monty Python and the Holy Grail — perhaps the only Python that meets these criteria. The others? Run away! Run away! Clue — perfect for board game fans, and the three alternate endings reward a second viewing.

Also in this category: Airplane II · The Naked Gun, all three · Police Squad! · Top Secret! · Hot Shots! · Spaceballs · Robin Hood: Men in Tights · The Great Muppet Caper · The Pink Panther and A Shot in the Dark · Asterix & Obelix: Mission Cleopatra · Murder by Death

One caution on that last one. Murder by Death parodies the entire detective canon and pits Peter Falk against Alec Guinness, but Peter Sellers plays Sidney Wang in yellowface — so decide in advance whether you want to spend the evening explaining 1976.

Comic competence, heroes too silly to endanger

The Court Jester (1955) — a hypnotist snaps Danny Kaye into a master swordsman and snaps him back into a coward, so the climactic duel keeps flipping him mid-thrust against Basil Rathbone, a championship fencer playing straight opposite a man who cannot fence. The pellet with the poison’s in the vessel with the pestle. Ghostbusters — the only film here with an actual ghost and no actual dread. See it big, for reasons I come to below. Dungeons & Dragons: Honor Among Thieves — already tested in our household, though an empty post-COVID theatre let us heckle the screen with impunity.

Also in this category: Big Trouble in Little China · Hot Fuzz · Bill & Ted’s Excellent Adventure · The Blues Brothers · The Road to El Dorado

Formal artifice, stylization holds you at arm’s length

Wallace & Gromit: The Wrong Trousers — a train chase in plasticine registers as engineering rather than escape. Paddington 2 — Hugh Grant hams magnificently and the prison turns pastel, which puts warmth exactly where cynicism would otherwise sit. The Princess Bride — romance drives the plot and the film passes anyway, because the grandfather interrupts to announce that she does not get eaten by the eels. Fred Savage does the defusing on the audience’s behalf.

Also in this category: Fantastic Mr. Fox · The Hobbit (Rankin/Bass, 1977) · The Flight of Dragons · The Muppet Movie · Wallace & Gromit: A Close Shave and The Curse of the Were-Rabbit

Tabletop-native

The Gamers: Dorkness Rising — made by people who have argued about initiative order, and free on YouTube besides. Heat Vision and Jack — an unaired Ben Stiller pilot in which sunlight makes Jack Black a genius and Owen Wilson voices the motorcycle.

And skip these

The exclusions carry more information than the recommendations, so here they run with reasons.

Galaxy Quest — opening cynicism, which no later warmth redeems for a viewer who already left. Back to the Future — bullying as structure plus romance as engine, a double failure. The Neverending Story — Artax sinks in the Swamp of Sadness, and a boy goes into a dumpster in scene one. Time Bandits — too Brazil, and the parents explode. The Martian — competence and wisecracks throughout, then the tarp comes off. Knives Out — real suspense under the comedy. The Iron Giant — earns its gut punch and delivers it anyway. Watership Down, Old Yeller, Bambi — I cannot watch two of these myself.

One complication belongs in the record. Ghostbusters worked on me in a theatre and died on a laptop decades later, which had nothing to do with tension and everything to do with scale. Some films manage spectacle rather than threat, and shrinking the screen breaks the wrong thing. Presentation belongs in the criteria too.

My son may qualify as rare. He does not qualify as alone. A generation grew up holding the remote, learned that skipping costs nothing and arrived at a tolerance the industry never thought to measure — and if yours sits beside you doing the same arithmetic, start with Clue.

Any more ideas for films that meet these criteria? Send them by unladen swallow to [email protected]. African or European, I’m not fussy.

← All writing

Join the conversation.

Occasional notes on the book, research in progress, and dispatches from a growing network of academics, practitioners, and others working on poverty. No more than once a month.

Free · Unsubscribe anytime